Vivold Consulting
Policy & Regulation

Anthropic wins ruling on AI training in copyright lawsuit but must face trial on pirated books

Key Insights

A federal judge ruled that Anthropic's use of copyrighted books to train its AI is fair use but must face trial over allegations of using pirated copies.

Stay Updated

Get the latest insights delivered to your inbox

A federal judge has ruled that AI company Anthropic did not violate U.S. copyright law by training its Claude chatbot on millions of copyrighted books, deeming the use 'quintessentially transformative' and therefore fair use. However, Anthropic must face trial in December over allegations it illegally downloaded those books from pirated online libraries. The lawsuit, brought by authors Andrea Bartz, Charles Graeber, and Kirk Wallace Johnson, accuses Anthropic of large-scale theft to profit from the intellectual labor in those books. Internal documents showed employee concerns over the legality of using pirated sources. Although Anthropic later began purchasing and digitizing books more lawfully, the judge stated that prior piracy could still incur liability. The outcome of this case may influence similar lawsuits against other AI companies like OpenAI and Meta. Anthropic expressed satisfaction with the fair use ruling but did not comment on the piracy allegations. Founded in 2021 by former OpenAI members, Anthropic promotes itself as a responsible AI developer, but the lawsuit challenges this image.

More in Policy & Regulation

All Policy & Regulation stories

Texas slams the brakes on data centres - and the AI buildout's easiest frontier just closed

Governor Greg Abbott announced that all new Texas data-centre projects must be audited by the Public Utility Commission and grid operator ERCOT - a sharp turn for a state whose loose regulation and cheap power made it second only to Virginia for data centres. The trigger is a staggering queue: ERCOT's interconnection requests doubled from 233GW in January to 474GW, about 90% data centres, more than five times the grid's all-time peak demand. Audits will demand power and water use, noise mitigation, light controls, tax-incentive use, and ownership details - after a voluntary survey that most operators simply ignored.

Apple sues OpenAI for trade-secret theft - alleging the scheme ran 'at every level'

Apple sued OpenAI in federal court in Northern California for trade secret theft and breach of contract, alleging former Apple employees took confidential material to benefit OpenAI's consumer hardware ambitions - and that the misconduct was directed by senior leadership, running, in Apple's words, from members of technical staff to the Chief Hardware Officer. Specific claims include an engineer who allegedly kept an Apple laptop and downloaded confidential documents, and OpenAI allegedly using Apple's proprietary metal-finishing technique by misleading a shared supplier into believing it had permission. IO Products is also named. OpenAI says it has no interest in others' trade secrets.

AWS just published the ROI case for GraphRAG: drug research cycles cut by 87%

An AWS GraphRAG deployment in pharmaceutical research cut R&D cycles by 87% - initial discovery that took six months now closes in three weeks - by fusing siloed internal databases and public literature into one queryable knowledge graph on Amazon Neptune Analytics and Bedrock (running Claude). Every answer comes with verifiable citations and a mapped reasoning path, which is exactly what regulated industries need for compliance. The architecture is modular and, crucially, transferable: any enterprise drowning in fragmented legacy data can copy this pattern.